Skip to content

I bought these Sea Tales Sardines in Water at a place I wouldn't normally think to look for sardines. But I had read online they sometimes have them there, and at a bargain price. To be honest, if these weren't the only ones they had on hand, they would have been my last choice. I don't usually buy sardines packed in water, but another brand I tried recently wasn't all that bad, so I went ahead and got them. They were cheap compared to the brand's regular price, and I thought at $3 there wouldn't be anything to lose.

Initial impression upon opening the can: Meh...

They're really roughed-up looking. Three in the can. The wrapper claims hand packed. The aroma is a little fishy. A taste of the water, which has become sort of broth-like, is encouraging. But that's where the encouragement ends.

The first, nearly skinless one breaks apart as it's plucked from the can. The flavor is bland, reminiscent of cheaper boneless skinless pilchards. I checked the can for sodium content. Only 105mg, which is quite low. More salt might have saved these, but I doubt it. To be quite honest, this may be the first can in over a hundred I've tried that I've considered not finishing, just trashing the rest. And probably throwing away the second can I bought as well. There was nothing appealing about them, neither visually nor otherwise. Disappointing.

Main Takeaways
  • Thought I was getting a bargain
  • Visually unappealing
  • Needed salt

Brand: Sea Tales
Description: Sardines in water
Species: Pilchards
Country of Origin: Portugal
Source: FAO27, Northeast Atlantic
Skin/Bones: Yes/Yes
Net Wt: 4.2 oz.
Price Range: $5-6

I got these Sea Tales Sardines in Extra Virgin Olive Oil on sale at Whole Foods mainly to give the brand a try. I figured I should start with their basic sardines in EVOO.

Initial impression upon opening the can: 3/5.

he first thing you notice when you open the can is that it's two large, fat, humongous pilchards. Maybe it's not like that all the time, but this time it was. To be honest, for the money spent on these, I'd really rather a can of pilchards be 3 to 5 fish; a bigger fish means bigger spines and bones. Also, there were more scales than I expected to see at this price point.

On the upside, these had a fairly clean aroma and taste, which is good. The olive oil tastes blandly neutral, not quite what one would expect of a good EVOO.

The package, which uses a paper overwrap typical of some of the premium tinned fish brands, has some nice verbiage about family and Cornwall, UK history. But these are produced in Portugal. I later learned it wasn't uncommon for Cornish fishing fleets to bring their catch across the Bay of Biscay to Portugal, either for processing or for sale.

These also come in a "EVOO with lemon" version, but I'm now ambivalent about trying them. I'm going to try to look online to see if this "two big fish per can" is a regular thing or not.

See it at Amazon.

Brand: Sea Tales
Description: Sardines in Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Species: Pilchards
Country of Origin: Portugal
Source: FAO27, Northeast Atlantic
Skin/Bones: Yes/Yes
Net Wt: 4.2 oz.
Price Range: $5-6